General Forum
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
Confused

Are either of the following sentences correct?

Michael's and my bed is hard as a board.

Mine and Michael's bed is hard as a board.

Thanks,

Annie

Re: Confused

The first one is nothing close to correct. :P The second one would be correct if it was "Mine and Michael's bed is >>AS<< hard as a board." Then it will be correct.

Hope I helped!
Travis

Re: Confused

Thank you, Travis. Of course.

Annie

Re: Confused

This is a good question. (I'm assuming the missing "as" is a typo.)

Re: Michael's and my bed is as hard as a board.

This version is better than the one below, because it is more clear that you are talking about one bed. To make it even clearer, you could say "My and Michael's bed.

Re: Mine and Michael's bed is as hard as a board.

This version could also be talking about one bed, but logically it aligns better to talking about two beds. Remember, "mine" is an absolute possessive pronoun. Here "mine" means "my bed". It does not modify "bed" like an adjective. So, it should be "mine and Michael's bed are..."

I hope that helps.

Re: Confused

Thank you, GM. I must admit the missing 'as' was a temporary (I hope) brain malfunction rather than a typo.

Yes, I am referring to one bed, which is why I've struggled with how to form the sentence, so your suggestions do make sense.

In the second example, if I was referring to two beds should it be 'Mine and Michael's beds are as hard as boards'?

Annie