General Forum
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
Helping verb

Can you please explain the answer for the sentences below:

Sally_______(could/couldn't)play the flute, however. She always makes lovely music with it.

Cathy_______(could/couldn't)swim though.She is a member of the swimming team.

What do however and though mean?

Thanks

Re: Helping verb

Can you please explain the answer for the sentences below:

Sally_______(could/couldn't)play the flute, however. She always makes lovely music with it.

Cathy_______(could/couldn't)swim though.She is a member of the swimming team.

What do however and though mean?

Thanks[/quote]

Re: Helping verb

Sally couldn't play sport because her legs are paralysed. Sally could play the flute, however. She always makes lovely music with it.

The second sentence can be written two ways:
Sally could play the flute, however.
and
However, Sally could play the flute.

however: it is an adverb and used in a statement that contrasts with or seems to contradict something that has been said previously: her ability to play the flute contrasts with her inability to play sport.

Cathy couldn't play any musical instrument and wasn't very good academically. Cathy could swim though. She is a member of the swimming team.

though: an adverb. Can you see how the first sentence makes it seem as if poor Cathy wasn't any good at anything.
Then we find out that she IS good at something - swimming. So you see, it is very much the same as 'however'.

So - I could write that sentence two ways:
Cathy couldn't play any musical instrument and wasn't very good academically. Cathy could swim though. She is a member of the swimming team.

and

Cathy couldn't play any musical instrument and wasn't very good academically. However, Cathy could swim. She is a member of the swimming team.