General Forum
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
difference in meaning

What is the difference in meaning between the following sentences.
1. How beautiful is the rain?
2. How beautiful is the rain!
Thanks in advance.

Re: difference in meaning



What do you think is the difference?

PaulM

Re: difference in meaning

I can't say it.

Re: difference in meaning


Consider the effect of the word "how" on the sentence, and ask yourself if you're really asking a question.

PaulM

Re: difference in meaning

Thanks, PaulM.
May I ask a question?
Does the sentence "How beautiful is the rain!" mean "The rain is very beautiful."?

Re: difference in meaning

It's possible, but that's not the usual construction. This is all about the grammar of "exclamatives"; here's how they work:

If you want to exclaim that the rain is very beautiful, then you should not invert the subject and the auxiliary, so you would say "How beautiful the rain is! Normally, inverting the subject and verb makes a question. Compare:

(1) How old he is! (exclamative)
(2) How old is he? (question)

Ex (1) is an exclamative; there is no subject-verb inversion. Exclamative "how" indicates a high degree - it comments on him being amazingly old. Ex (2) by contrast is a question; it has subject-verb inversion - it merely asks how old he is.

Exclamatives also occur with "what". Compare:

(3) What a car that was! (exclamative)
(4) What car was that? (question)

Ex (3) is an exclamative; there is no inversion. Exclamative "what" is concerned with quality or degree - it was a remarkable car. Ex (4) on the other hand is a question; it has subject-verb inversion; here "what" questions identity - the answer to the question will identify the relevant car.

Do you see what I mean?

PaulM