General Forum
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
"is needing" - is this correct?

I saw this on an email:

"Customer is needing a wiring diagram for these serial numbers. "


Shouldn't it be "Customer needs a wiring diagram..."?
Is it grammatically correct to use "is needing" in a sentence?


Thanks!

Re: "is needing" - is this correct?

The use of the verb "need" in progressive constructions is only marginally acceptable, and then only in some dialects. You'll hear it quite often in the Scottish variety of English, as in Ay, I daresay you'll be needing a good breakfast afore ye go!

But when it comes to Standard English, you are right that "The customer needs a wiring diagram" is the correct form.

PaulM

Re: "is needing" - is this correct?

Paul Matthews
The use of the verb "need" in progressive constructions is only marginally acceptable, and then only in some dialects. You'll hear it quite often in the Scottish variety of English, as in Ay, I daresay you'll be needing a good breakfast afore ye go!

But when it comes to Standard English, you are right that "The customer needs a wiring diagram" is the correct form.

PaulM



Okay, thanks.