Forum: General Forum
Start a New Topic 
  
Author
Comment
It is the closest the club have came to ending their wait.

As this sentence is the present perfect tense, why does it sound clumsy?
Why is it not for example 'It is the closest the club have come to ending their wait'
Answers please. Thanks.

Re: It is the closest the club have came to ending their wait.

Clumsy, and grammatically incorrect.
There is an aberration taking strong hold in America, where the Present Perfect and Past Perfect tenses are now formed as:

has/had + Simple Past Tense !!!
"...but I had went to the movies."

You are right. Those tenses are formed:
has/had + Past Participle.
'club' can be regarded as singular or plural. I presume the writer regards 'waiting' as referring to the individual members, and so, regards it as plural.

It is the closest the club have come to ending their wait.

Re: It is the closest the club have came to ending their wait.

Thank you Gervais for the reply.
I think if I were (past subjunctive) to teach this I would correct it to the simple past by removing the incorrect auxiliary "have".
So: It is the closest the club came to ending their wait.
Thanks again for your reply.
Uncle Gary.