General Forum
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
View Entire Thread
Re: Appositive & Appositive phrase

If you are American, then the 'false title' "British explorer and navigator" is regarded as an appositive, identifying the noun "Matthew Flinders" (note the correct spelling of "Matthew').

It is a variation on:
Matthew Flinders, the British explorer and navigator, was...
The omission of the 'the' in your original "British explorer and navigator Matthew Flinders" began with journalists, but has become accepted in the mainstream.

Question 2: is the appositive in this sentence essential or nonessential?

A person has only one father, so this identifies the person. His actual name is interesting, but nonessential.

It should be written:

His father, Auguste Piccard, designed the bathyscaphe.

Re: Appositive & Appositive phrase

Claire
If you are American, then the 'false title' "British explorer and navigator" is regarded as an appositive, identifying the noun "Matthew Flinders" (note the correct spelling of "Matthew').
I disagree:

British explorer and navigator, Matthew Flinders, was the first to chart the coastline.

The NP "British explorer and navigator" could not possibly be an appositive modifier because it is head of the matrix NP (underlined). The appositive NP is in fact "Matthew Flinders". Appositives are post head modifiers (they follow the head they modify), not pre-head ones, so that rules out the NP "British explorer and navigator".


It is a variation on:
Matthew Flinders, the British explorer and navigator, was...
The omission of the 'the' in your original "British explorer and navigator Matthew Flinders" began with journalists, but has become accepted in the mainstream.

Reversing the NPs means that "Matthew Flinders" becomes head of the matrix NP, and inserting the determiner “the” in "the British explorer and navigator" means that it is now an appositive. This is evident from the fact that "The British explorer and navigator was the first to chart the coastline" is a genuine entailment of the original sentence.

However, omitting the determiner "the" to give "British explorer and navigator" changes things. This construction does not qualify as apposition because it cannot be substituted for the whole construction in such a way as to yield an entailment of the original, the bare role NP being unable to take over the subject function: *"British explorer and navigator was the first to chart the coastline".

PaulM

Re: Appositive & Appositive phrase

British explorer and navigator Matthew Finders was the first to chart the coastline.

this sentence is written in my Grammar,usage, and mechanics workbook by holt mcdougel (wrong spelling) there must be an appositive/phrase.. i'm confuced

Re: Appositive & Appositive phrase

Mr. Matthews fails to grasp that the omission of the 'the' was a journalistic rendition of 'The British explorer and navigator", and has practice has entered the mainstream. THEY ARE NOW REGARDED AS EQUIVALENT - BOTH ARE ACCEPTABLE.

Re: Appositive & Appositive phrase

Claire
Mr. Matthews fails to grasp that the omission of the 'the' was a journalistic rendition of 'The British explorer and navigator", and has practice has entered the mainstream. THEY ARE NOW REGARDED AS EQUIVALENT - BOTH ARE ACCEPTABLE.



Totally irrelevant. Appositives by definition are post-head modifiers, i.e. they always follow the noun they modify. So with or without a determiner, the NP "British explorer and navigator" cannot possibly be an appositive in the example that was submitted.

Here are some other examples:

The murderer, the man with the scar, will be arrested soon.
A university lecturer, Dr Brown, was arrested for the crime.
A surprise present, a bouquet of roses, was delivered to my door.

In those three examples, the appositives are in bold, and the NP's they modify are underlined, not the other way round!


PaulM

Re: Appositive & Appositive phrase

Zack
British explorer and navigator Matthew Finders was the first to chart the coastline.

this sentence is written in my Grammar,usage, and mechanics workbook by holt mcdougel (wrong spelling) there must be an appositive/phrase.. i'm confuced


Hi Zack

No need to be confused!

The appositive in your example is "Matthew Flinders". It modifies the NP "British explorer and navigator".

That is the only possibility.

PaulM